18 Best Siesta Key Restaurants On The Water

Spearfish Grille at the Siesta Key Marina offers modern fish and seafood in a casually rustic setting. It offers quality interpretations of classic dishes and innovative takes on island cuisine.

The interior, designed by marina owners, combines the trendy vibes of the beach with nods to the marina's and local fishing community's heritage at this Siesta Key restaurants on the beach.

The main focus of this grill is fresh, locally caught seafood like shrimp, hogfish, and grouper. Offers a blend of classic and creatively innovative island cuisine, focusing on exceptionally fresh local fish.

The best restaurants in Sarasota on the water provides indoor and outdoor dining options, including a cozy patio area amid coconut palms and a custom fire pit.

Some Must-Try dishes: Sushi Nachos, Fish Tacos, and hogfish Islamorada

• Address: 1265 Old Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242
• Hours: 11 am to 10 pm
• Contact: +1 941-349-1971
• Menu: places.singleplatform.com

Located near the point of Big Sarasota Pass, you can go to Siesta Key Summer House is known for serving top-notch steaks and seafood. The place has a relaxed yet stylish atmosphere with a modern interior design, making it suitable for various occasions.

Whether you're planning a romantic date or a family meal, Summer House has something for everyone. While it's a relatively new spot, it's quickly gaining popularity. Some standout dishes are the colossal lobster tail and the flavorful diver scallops.

And don't miss out on starting your meal with the charcuterie board - it's perfect for sharing with friends or someone special. Come to this Summer House for a dining experience that combines freshness, deliciousness, and a warm, welcoming vibe.

• Address: 149 Avenida Messina, FL 342
• Contact: +1 941-260-2675
• Hours: 4 am to 10 pm
• Menu: siestakeysummerhouse.com

Step into this paradise for cozy waterfront dining rooms and a breezy open-air patio. It provides stunning views of Little Sarasota Bay. 

Here, you can witness tropical birds gliding over preserved mangrove islands, catch glimpses of leaping dolphins, and feel the gentle caress of the breeze on your skin.

The laid-back tropical ambiance is just right for unwinding with friends or family. Conveniently located near Turtle Beach Resort and Inn, Ophelia on the Bay Sarasota is a stone’s throw away.

The menu is a daily delight, showcasing fresh, seasonal ingredients. Whether you're a seafood lover or a meat enthusiast, there's something to satisfy every palate.

Dishes To Try On: Maine Lobster Bisque, a Duo of Chilled Shellfish, and Steak Tartare of Beef Tenderloin

• Address: 9105 Midnight Pass Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242
• Contact: +1 941-349-2212
• Menu: opheliasonthebay.net

Featuring two outdoor patios, it is celebrated for its charming beach cottage ambiance and dedication to serving coastal-inspired cuisine with a modern twist.

The Cottage Restaurant Siesta Key menu often features a range of seafood options and creative dishes that showcase seasonal, locally sourced ingredients. Additionally, a substantial portion of the menu is dedicated to tapas, allowing diners to share and savor various dishes.

This blend of local flavors and communal dining makes The Cottage restaurants in Siesta Key a standout experience. The restaurant also has a reputation for its friendly and attentive staff, making it a favorite among locals and visitors. 

Must Try Dishes: Tuna Poke Tostados,  Edamame Hummus, and Tuna Tacoshimi

• Address: 153 Avenida Messina, FL 34242
• Contact: +1 941-312-9300
• Hours: 11 am to 10 pm

Renowned for its charming, rustic Italian ambiance and dedication to serving authentic Italian cuisine, the restaurant offers indoor and outdoor seating options, providing a versatile dining experience. 

The menu typically features many traditional Italian dishes, including pasta, seafood, and delectable desserts. The wine selection complements the menu with various Italian and international options.

With its warm and welcoming atmosphere, Cafe Gabbiano Restaurant Sarasota is a favorite among locals and visitors, making it a must-visit for anyone seeking an authentic Italian dining experience.

Must Try Dishes: Branzino al Sale, Lobster Ravioli, and Osso Buco

• Address: 5104 Ocean Blvd, FL 34242
• Contact: +1 941-349-1423
• Hours: 5 pm to 10 pm
• Menu: cafegabbiano.com

Turtles Restaurant Siesta Key Florida is not only celebrated for its delectable cuisine but also for its warm and welcoming ambiance. The establishment has become a cornerstone of South since its inception in 1986.

The restaurant's laid-back atmosphere perfectly complements its menu. Whether you opt for an al fresco dining experience or a cozy spot indoors with equally captivating waterside vistas, Turtles promises a memorable time.

This restaurants Sarasota menu typically features diverse seafood dishes, including fresh catches and classic preparations. The restaurant aims to provide a laid-back, casual atmosphere where patrons can enjoy their meals with a view of the Gulf Coast.

Must-try Dishes: Sea Scallops, Fried Gulf Shrimp Platter, and Turtles Salad

• Address: 8875 Midnight Pass Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242
• Contact: +1 941-346-2207
• Hours: 11:30 am to 9 pm
• Menu: urtlesrestaurant.com

This bar is a long-standing seafood restaurant in Sarasota. Established in 1972, it has become a beloved institution known for its relaxed, family-friendly atmosphere and emphasis on fresh seafood.

The menu at Captain Curts Siesta Key FL features a wide range of seafood options, including crabs, oysters, and other popular seafood items like shrimp, fish, and clams. They also offer non-seafood options for those who prefer different types of dishes.

In addition to its diverse seafood offerings, it is known for its casual, beachy decor and welcoming environment. It's a popular spot for locals and tourists alike, drawing in a mix of families, seafood enthusiasts, and those simply looking for a laid-back dining experience.

Must Try Dishes: Crab Legs, Oysters (in various preparations), and Shrimp Scampi

• Address: 1200 Old Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242
• Contact: +1 941-349-3885
• Hours: 11 am to 10 pm
• Menu: captaincurts.com

Bonjour French Cafe is a must-visit for its authentic French culinary experience. Enjoy delicious pastries and classic French dishes made with skill and attention to detail.

The cafe's commitment to using quality ingredients and traditional cooking techniques ensures a memorable dining experience. The warm and inviting atmosphere creates a cozy setting for a leisurely meal.

From flaky croissants to rich coq au vin, every dish embodies the essence of French cuisine. Immerse yourself in French culture without leaving your neighborhood, making Bonjour French Cafe a gem for food enthusiasts and Francophiles.

Must Try Dishes: Sandwich Baguette with Farm Lox, Italian Caprese Salad, and Baked Brie Croissant

• Address: 5214 Ocean Blvd, FL 34242
• Contact: +1 941-346-0600
• Hours: 7 am to 3 pm
• Menu: bonjourfrenchcafe.com

The cafe is often a beloved local spot, known for its delicious food and friendly staff, making it a go-to for many. It offers a diverse and inventive menu with comprehensive breakfast and brunch options, including unique twists on classic dishes. 

Another Broken Egg Cafe is centrally located at the four-way stop of Avenida Messina and Ocean Boulevard. Known for using fresh, quality ingredients, it ensures that every dish is made with care and attention to flavor.

It often provides a warm and welcoming ambiance, making it an inviting place to enjoy a meal with friends or family. Whether you want sweet or savory breakfasts or have specific dietary needs, their menu has something for everyone. 

Must Try Dishes: Fresh fruits and Honey waffles, Chicken and Waffles, and Country Power Bowl

• Address: 140 Avenida Messina, FL 34242
• Contact: +1 941-552-8320
• Hours: 7 am to 2 pm
• Menu: anotherbrokenegg.com

You'll discover the perfect blend of live music, top-notch drinks, and a local atmosphere at this place. This laid-back bar and eatery provides an authentic experience, with waterfront views rivaling a five-star resort.

Siesta Key Oyster Bar Sarasota Florida is a prime spot for locals and visitors, located just a brief stroll from the stunning Big Sarasota Pass beaches The casual atmosphere is inviting, making it an ideal spot to unwind with friends or family.

Whether you're a seafood enthusiast or just looking for a taste of local flavors, SKOB offers a diverse menu to satisfy all palates. The proximity to the beach and the energetic vibe make it a favorite among locals and visitors, ensuring a memorable time.

Must Try Dishes: Oysters (Half-shell dozen), Specialty Baked Oysters, and Chipotle Lobster Tacos

• Address: 5238 Ocean Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34242
• Contact: +1 941-346-5443
• Hour: 11 am to 11 pm
• Menu: skob.com

Nestled in the northern corner of the Village, it offers a unique local scratch kitchen experience. It offers a diverse selection of craft beers and drinks, making it the perfect place to enjoy a satisfying meal with a tasty beverage.

Island House Siesta Key is the best spot for tasty pub food or fresh seafood. Guests can dine or enjoy drinks and food in the outdoor seating area.

If you're looking for a light bite or a full meal, Island House Tap & Grill has something to suit your appetite. Their wide range of craft beers complements the delicious offerings from the local scratch kitchen.

Dishes To Try: Cheese Quesadilla, Pescoda Bowl, and I.H. Wedge Salad

• Address: 5110 Ocean Blvd, FL 34242
• Contact: +1 941-487-8116
• Hours: 11 am to 10 pm
• Menu: islandhousetapandgrill.com

It is a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts and anyone craving fresh, flavorful dishes. With a focus on quality and a wide selection of seafood, this establishment promises a delectable experience.

The grill offers a tempting array of cooked dishes, expertly prepared to highlight the natural flavors of the ocean's bounty.  The inviting atmosphere and dedicated staff create a welcoming environment for guests to savor their meals.

Whether you're a seafood lover or simply seeking a memorable dining experience, this Seafood Joint is a prime destination. From market to grill, it delivers an authentic taste of the sea right to your plate.

Must Try Dishes: Peel n Eat Shrimp, Gulf Shrimp Plate, and Tuna Tacos

• Address: 217 Avenida Madera, Sarasota, FL 34242
• Contact: +1 941-552-8826
• Hours: 4:30 pm to 9 pm

It is a must-visit destination for those seeking a refined dining experience on Siesta Key. The restaurant offers a fusion of contemporary American cuisine, focusing on fresh seafood and succulent steaks. 

The skilled culinary team ensures each dish is perfectly prepared, promising a memorable and palate-pleasing meal. The ambiance balances sophistication and warmth, making it an ideal choice for special occasions or intimate gatherings.

The welcoming staff adds to the overall charm, providing attentive service that enhances the dining experience. Claytons Siesta Grille guarantees an unforgettable culinary journey with its dedication to culinary excellence and inviting atmosphere.

Dishes To Indlung: Filet Mignon, Pan-Seared Sea Bass, and Lobster Risotto

• Address: 1256 Old Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242
• Contact: +1 941-349-2800
• Hours: 4 pm to 10 pm
• Menu: places.singleplatform.com

The Grill and Bar charm lies in the relaxed, beachy atmosphere that effortlessly captures the essence of coastal living. The menu boasts an array of mouthwatering seafood options, reflecting the freshness of the local catches. 

The culinary offerings will satisfy any seafood enthusiast. Additionally, Gilligan's is renowned for its tropical drink selection. The bar exudes a lively energy, often enhanced by live music, creating a vibrant and entertaining backdrop for guests.

With indoor and outdoor seating, patrons can dine al fresco, soaking in the sea breeze. Overall, this Siesta Key Village restaurants promises a delightful and authentic coastal dining experience that captures the spirit of the city.

What To Try: Seafood Boil, Grilled Fish, and Seafood Pasta

• Address: 5253 Ocean Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34242
• Contact: +1 941-346-8122
• Hours: 11 am to 2 pm

This restaurant likely offers a diverse menu of delicious and convenient options that are perfect for enjoying by the shore. It offers a diverse menu, from refreshing smoothies to satisfying burgers and crisp salads, catering to various tastes and preferences.

The convenience of having such a diverse and delicious selection right at the beach ensures that you can make the most of your time in the sun and surf without having to stray far for a satisfying meal.

With its beachfront location and mouthwatering offerings, Siesta Beach Eats adds an extra layer of enjoyment to your beach day, making it a must-visit destination.

Must Try: Loaded Cheese Fries, Siesta Salad, and Double Cheeseburger

• Address: 948 Beach Rd, FL 34242
• Hours: 9 am to 5 pm

Siesta Key Beach restaurants is a special place in Sarasota with a unique view of the water. It's one of the few places to see boats and yachts going up and down the waterway.

You can also watch the Stickney Point drawbridge go up and down while you eat. Inside, there's a bar called "The Reef Bar," where they have a happy hour every day from 4 to 7 p.m.

The indoor dining rooms are bright and spacious and fit many people, especially during the busy season. The outside deck with tables and umbrellas is viral, especially during busy times.

What To Eat: Jumbo Shrimp, Chicken Alfredo, and Crab Legs

• Address: 1500 Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34231
• Contact: +1 941-921-6200
• Hours: 11 am to 9 pm
• Menu: boatyardwaterfrontgrill.com

This vibrant place is renowned for its extensive selection of frozen daiquiris in various tempting flavors. Whether you prefer classic fruit blends or unique concoctions, there's a daiquiri to suit every taste.

The lively ambiance, live music, and entertainment create an energetic setting for socializing and enjoying the island vibes. With indoor and outdoor seating options, Daiquiri Deck Siesta Key Sarasota is an ideal spot to relax, unwind, and soak up the lively atmosphere.

It also offers a diverse menu featuring casual American cuisine, perfect for refueling after a day at the beach or before a night out in Siesta Key Village.

Must Try: Classic Burger, Fish Tacos, and Buffalo Chicken Wrap

• Address: 1250 Stickney Point Rd, FL 34242
• Contact: +1 941-312-2422
• Hours: 11 am to 10 pm
• Menu: daiquirideck.com

The Toasted Mango Sarasota Florida offers a dining experience that blends flavor, freshness, and creativity. Its diverse menu caters to various palates, ensuring something for everyone.

The star ingredient, mango, is skillfully incorporated into various dishes, infusing a unique and tropical twist. This creates a delightful culinary adventure that sets the cafe apart.

The inviting ambiance and friendly staff also create a warm, welcoming atmosphere, making it an ideal spot for casual gatherings or leisurely solo dining.

Ultimately, dining at the Toasted Mango Cafe is more than just a meal; it's an experience that tantalizes the taste buds, celebrates fresh flavors, and leaves patrons with a lasting impression of culinary excellence.

What To Eat: Mango Stuffed French Toast, Blackened Grouper Sandwich, and Mango Chicken Salad

• Address: 6621 Midnight Pass Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242
• Contact: +1 941-552-6485
• Hour: 7:30 am to 2:30 pm
• Menu: toastedmangocafe.com