13 Best Key Lime Pie In Key West

The Key Lime Pie Bakery is just one block away from Duval Street. This place is frequented by cruise ship visitors.

There are several key lime pie options available here. You have the option of eating the entire pie or simply a piece, which can also be covered in chocolate.

On their adorable green seats outside, make sure to take pictures, and enjoy your Key Lime Pie while people-watching.

Additionally, you can get ideal Key Lime concentrate here to make Key Lime Pie once you return from the Florida Keys, whether as a present or for yourself.

The 'Best Key Lime Pie in Key West' accolade was given to Kermit by the Food Network.

Locals must concur that Kermit's serves up some of Key West's greatest key lime pies. The Key Lime Pie served at Kermit's has a classic graham cracker crust made with butter and whipped cream.

Pick between a whole pie, a slice, or a frozen Key Lime Pie on a stick that has been wrapped in chocolate. If you visit Kermit's Key Lime Shoppe, you'll be in pie bliss.

They dip their frozen pie bars in delectable Belgian chocolate. A cool beverage on a warm day under the Key West heat.

Because of its Key lime pie florida keys success, a second site in Key West was established. They serve breakfast, lunch, and of course Key Lime Pie at their Elizabeth Street location.

Good salads and wraps may be found at Kermit's Cafe if you need a fast, inexpensive meal.

A fantastic spot to find mementos with a pie theme is Kermit's. Kermit's apparel, Key Lime soap, and even Key Lime lip balm are available in their store.

Even Kermit Carpenter himself could be present. He'll be easy to spot with his essential lime green clothing.

• Address: 200 Elizabeth Street Key West, 431 Front Street, Key West
• Menu: keylimeshop.com

You'll like Key Lime Pie from Blue Heaven if you are not into tradition. They are renowned for their delicious pie with meringue on top.

Their pie with graham cracker crust has an excessively large 6-inch meringue served on top! Any person who likes meringue will experience sweet ecstasy after eating their pie.

Their appeal is not limited to Key Lime Pie. On its terrace, Blue Heaven hosts popular events like "Breakfast with the Roosters." 

Blue Heaven is among Key West's top eateries for breakfast. Their key lime pie recipe with cream cheese is the best seller.

The atmosphere here is shabby bohemian. An eccentric visit is made possible with plastic seats, a temporary bar with a tin roof, and improvised signage.

Since there are no reservations, arrive early. Enjoy roosters crowing as you eat pancakes, handmade granola, banana bread, and other dishes.

• Address: 729 Thomas St., Key West
• Menu: blueheavenkw.com

The origins of this eatery, El Meson de Pepe, may be found in the sleepy Cuban village of Yaguajay.

The owner started cooking as a young man to stay out of the fields, and during those same adolescent years, he discovered his passion: cooking and food!

He subsequently traveled to Spain to begin his culinary career, honing his craft while working at well-known "Meson" establishments. He started working at the well-known Miami restaurant La Esquina De Tejas when he arrived there in 1973.

He even had the honor of cooking for US President Ronald Reagan at one point.

In 1986, he and his family finally launched and founded El Meson de Pepe, a restaurant serving traditional Cuban food.

Pepe's Cuban Nachos with guacamole cheese, the Conga Combo, Antojitos, Calamares Empanizados with Sala de Sofrito, and the Ensalada de Casa are some delectable favorites that patrons frequently eat at El Meson de Pepe.

Additionally, there are some wonderful sweets, such as Flan Casero, Coconut Flan, handmade key lime pie, caramel custard, and much more!

• Address: 410 Wall Street, Key West, FL 33040
• Phone: (305) 295-2620
• Menu: elmesondepepe.com

Visit a charming and laid-back eatery fittingly named The Cafe to try Key West's one and only vegan Key Lime Pie. Rock the Veg is the Cafe's catchphrase.

For anyone in your group who might not be too keen on the vegetable notion, there are some meat alternatives available on broad breakfast, brunch, lunch, and supper menus.

The Cafe not only sells delectable vegan Key Lime Pie. You may also try one of their five other vegan pies or pastries.

There are numerous excellent gluten-free choices available, so consider carrot cake and red velvet cake. You'll be happy you stopped by The Cafe to sample some of the greatest Key Lime Pie in Key West, which is only a half block off Duval Street.

The Moondog Cafe & Bakery is a great location for Instagram. There are paintings all throughout the property, some of which feature their adorable French Bulldog mascot.

It made an inviting and dynamic dining area with excellent design.

They provide breakfast, lunch, and dinner in addition to some of the best Key Lime Pies around. Additionally, they have a nice assortment of meals.

 Breakfast burritos, burgers, pizza, and bakery items, as well as the Quiche Lorraine. The bakery offers Key Lime Pie, eclairs, muffins, and zucchini bread in addition to croissants.

Many variations are also available that are vegan and gluten-free, such as a key lime pie recipe using cream cheese. Everybody can find something to like.

For the finest ambiance, it's a terrific place to have a seat in their little outside dining area. With the hanging lights and mingling visitors, it looks stunning at night.

• Address: 823 Whitehead St., Key West
• Phone: (305) 741-7699
• Menu: moondogcafe.com

The Key West Lime Pie Co.'s sweets are allegedly the most recognizable in the Florida Keys.

The little key lime fruit, which grows naturally in the area, inspired the name of the first batch of pies, which were created in the early 20th century. This desert became well-known thanks to the local fisherman, who also helped make it a favorite with Americans nationwide and in Florida.

A unique family recipe created by the owners of Key West Key Lime Pie Co. has been cherished and shared locally for many years.

In addition to being able to select a genuine key lime pie at this cafe, you can also enroll in pie-making workshops to go behind the scenes and discover how to create your very own miniature key lime pie in the café's kitchen!

Be sure to sample a traditional Key West key lime pie, six key lime pie chocolate-dipped bars, a gluten-free key lime pie, or gluten-free chocolate-dipped bars while you're at the café!

• Address: 511 Greene St, Key West, FL 33040
• Phone: (305) 517-6720
   

Founded by a family, the Old Town Bakery is a business. It began in a historic building in 2010.

To complement the bakery's traditional, hand-made baked goods, it required some time to repair the inside of the building while preserving its Key West beauty from the 19th century.

If you have a sweet tooth and value handcrafted goods, start with the dessert menu and choose pies like a conventional key lime pie, a chocolate walnut brownie, or a whole key lime pie.

Key lime pie in key west are well-known, decadent OMG brownies or some traditional, mouthwatering chocolate chip cookies.

The Old Town Bakery is crowded with locals and tourists who hurry to purchase baguettes, freshly baked loaves, and a range of artisan brands of bread.

For cheese aficionados, this eatery also has choices! Other delicious treats include sacristan, sticky buns, raspberry scones, apple cobbler Danish, blueberry cheese Danish, sticky buns, and other well-known American desserts.

• Address: 930 Eaton Street, Key West, FL 33040
• Phone: (305) 396-7450
• Menu: storage.snappages.site

Sarabeth's is a fantastic option for Key West's greatest Key Lime Pie. Both breakfast and dinner are frequently served there.

You may go there each day of the week to get one of Key West's greatest breakfasts. They also provide delicious meals like vegetarian burgers and quesadillas.

They take great satisfaction in their innovative and sophisticated spins on traditional American meals. A favorite among guests is the Lemon Ricotta Pancakes. 

A creative take on a traditional morning delight is their Key Lime Pie French Toast.

A slice of Sarabeth's Key Lime Pie is a must-have dessert. They employ an old-fashioned, flavorful Key Lime Pie recipe. Orange, Strawberry Shortcake, and Chocolate Pudding are some further well-liked sweets.

• Address: 530 Simonton St., Key West
• Menu: sarabethskw.com

The owners of Key Lime Republic are enthusiastic about their restaurant and truly believe that "Key lime is the key to everything!"

Their motto, "a world of key lime" at your fingertips, also acts as their driving concept. The customer who is excited to eat the delectable, authentic Key West key lime pie thinks this sounds fantastic!

You can take a break to have brunch, lunch, or a nice cup of coffee.

Eggs cooked in any way and Cuban bread with butter and some hot cheese are two delicious breakfast alternatives to try.

For vegetarians and vegans, a veggie burger sandwich is a satisfying lunch choice. There are a few other options as well, including pulled pork, roast beef, tuna salad, and grilled chicken.

The range of desserts is fantastic! Try a real Coconut Key Lime Pie, a Key Lime Cheesecake, or even a gluten-free Key Lime Pie Cheesecake if you are sensitive to or allergic to gluten.

You won't even be able to tell you had any pie if you only eat a little piece of key lime pie.

• Address: 412 Greene St, Key West, FL 33040
• Menu: Key Lime Republic

One of Key West's top dining establishments, Cafe Marquesa is definitely worth a visit. One of the best restaurants in the neighborhood.

A supper with friends or a date would be ideal there. It has a beautiful ambiance, and you'll quickly see why so many people enjoy it.

You can choose between the duck breast or the crispy yellowtail snapper for supper. They are renowned for their house-made sweets in addition to their locally sourced Key West cuisine.

Their Key Lime Pie is exquisite and is topped with whipped cream and walnuts. Along with RumChata Limón, Key Lime Rum, and cream, they also sell a liquid Key Lime Pie. Just thinking about it makes me drool.

You must try it if you enjoy the key lime flavor.

This is one of the greatest locations to go to because of the flawless presentation and the mix of elegant and informal dining.

• Menu: marquesa.com
• Address: 600 Fleming St., Key West

The key lime pies from Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory in Tavernier have been featured in publications including Southern Living and Coastal Living.

The store offers key limes by the slice, whole, or frozen on a stick and coated in chocolate. All are made from a recipe handed down by the co-owner's grandmother.

A wide variety of other key lime goods, including cookies, pretzels, and candies, are also available.

The term Turtle Kraals comes from the Dutch African word meaning "corral." Green turtles were historically housed here before being shipped to other countries as a delicacy.

The green turtle population has significantly risen as a result of conservation initiatives implemented since the 1970s.

One could be seen if you look closely in the seas around Key West or Dry Tortugas National Park, which Ponce de Leon first called "Las Tortugas" (Spanish for "The Turtles") in 1513.

Look for their tiny heads, single-clawed flippers, and heart-shaped shells.